Center for Shared Insight, PC

3 Reasons Black and White Thinking Can Damage a Relationship

September 6, 2017
Posted By: Kristen Hick, Psy.D.
Man walking away from woman

Do you think in black and white or fifty shades of gray? Do you prefer absolutes, certainty, and a clear relationship path or a more spontaneous relationship journey? Do you spend too much time thinking about the ultimate outcome of a relationship rather than simply embracing the moments with your loved one?

Black and white thinking is a common relationship dynamic or defense mechanism, usually with one of the parties involved. This “either/or” thinking might include needing absolute answers about where the relationship stands, is going, and the associated timelines. It can sometimes manifest as a preoccupation with the next relationship milestone or the relationship status.

Black and white thinking can make it difficult for a relationship to endure, and here are three reasons why.

1. Premature decision-making

If you suffer from black-and-white thinking, you desire certainty. Therefore, you put situations and/or people in clear buckets like good/bad, healthy/destructive, all/nothing or right/wrong. When you fail to see the gray, it’s harder to come to a resolution about a relationship situation that might have been undesirable for a day, because your tendency is to categorize the entire relationship as “bad” after an “off” day with your partner.

Notice your desire to make a decision before you have all the facts and see the situation from all perspectives. A bad day in a relationship does not mean that the relationship is doomed. If you feel the tendency to “quit” on a relationship or break up with a partner after he/she upsets you or you have a bad day together, black-and-white thinking is probably the culprit. Instead, focus on the lessons in that conflict and how you can plan to overcome future, similar problems to keep the relationship strong.

2. Lack of compromise

Successful relationships are about give and take. They are about finding middle ground or a reasonable compromise. When you come into a relationship with unrealistic, predetermined needs and a desired path, you’ll be less likely to step into your partner’s shoes and see things from his/her point of view. And, empathy is a key element in a healthy relationship.

For instance, let’s pretend that you firmly believe that it’s important to wait six months before introducing your new partner to your kids. When the opportunity arises for a great family outing around month five, and your partner really wants to attend, if you are a black-and-white thinker, you might refuse to include your partner in that opportunity because it falls before that six-month threshold. This lack of compromise means you all miss out on the opportunity to enjoy the time together despite the relationship going really well in month five, along with the general sense that both parties are ready for that next milestone.

Remember: boundaries, such as timelines, are important in creating healthy relationships, but you also need to look at the “grey” area too, such as how do they treat you and others, how consistent are they, how do you feel about the person, and are you on a similar path together?

Choosing “the gray” or the middle ground in the situation might be including your partner in a casual way on a night out with your kids without making it feel like a giant, scary milestone for everyone involved. Perhaps you meet at the family-friendly event, and behave more like friends as a compromise for a one-month early introduction to the children. Choosing a shade of gray in this situation means choosing a compromise for the happiness and health of everyone involved.

3. Unrealistic Expectations

When you are an all-or-nothing thinker, you want to define the relationship clearly. Yet, couples have their ups and downs and rigid thinking can easily set you up for unrealistic expectations. Dating someone with black and white thinking means added pressure that the relationship meet certain thresholds for time together, intimacy, and/or a level of perfection. These expectations aren’t realistic as people, as well as couples, have on days and off days, and can’t be held long-term to a certain expectation of perfection.


Black and white thinking can sometimes be confused with healthy boundaries, which are limitations you might set to ensure you remain healthy within the relationship. These vary from black-and-white thinking as they are set with the intention of creating a healthier relationship rather than establishing rigid ultimatums. Boundaries can and should exist without the need for all-or-nothing scenarios.

Recognizing the resistance to living in uncertainty, even just briefly, is the first step to transformation. Recognize your tendency to obsess about the small things. Find ways to sit with uncomfortable feelings or unknowns about the future, embracing the not-knowing, and coming to terms with a tendency to judge, obsess, control outcomes, and over analyze details will go a long ways to finding just a single shade of gray on the relationship spectrum.

Talking with a therapist about having an absolute mindset can help you identify and overcome such thinking patterns and the associated defense mechanisms. A neutral third party can help provide feedback on the process of shifting behaviors to make permanent change. To learn more about the way Center for Shared Insight can support this transformation, schedule a free consultation with our team of relationship therapists.

Related Blog Posts
March 23, 2020
Dating in the Age of Social Distancing

We are navigating unknown waters with the COVID-19 pandemic affecting every aspect of life. With social distancing being the “new normal” for the foreseeable future, you might wonder “what does that mean for dating”? Perhaps “online dating” will take on a whole new meaning as we create new rituals around courtship.  

But, dating doesn’t have to be completely on hold during this time, it just needs to morph and evolve into something new. Much like you’ve seen with workplaces moving to remote structure and schools considering online ...

March 10, 2020
Podcast: Attachment Theory with Kristen Hick

Dr. Kristen Hick joined Dave Glaser from Believe Be Real Be Bold to record a Podcast about Attachment Theory. On the show, Dr. Hick reminds listeners that not intimately knowing oneself is what holds many individuals back in relationships. She dives into the types of attachment systems and the gravity and polarity those different ways of attaching impact relationships. Throughout this episode, both Dr. Hick and Dave share stories about their own dating and relationship challenges to illustrate how to identify and heal unresolved relationship experiences that ...

If you have difficulty using our website, please email us or call us at (720) 644-6698
View the ADA Accessibility Statement
This website is designed for general information only. The information presented on this site should not be construed to be formal psychological or mental health advice or treatment nor the formation of a therapist-client relationship.
CSIP UPDATE - Now offering In-Person and Online Therapy sessions (to COLORADO residents) during Covid-19!
Our therapists are here to help you during this uncertain time. We know you and others are trying to do your part to social distance due to Covid-19, which is why we are happy to provide online therapy sessions through our secure video platform.

Beginning June 8th, we will now be offering a limited number of in-person sessions in our office for those who prefer that option. We are here to talk with you about how we can meet your therapy needs. 
Contact us today to learn more!