Center for Shared Insight, PC

Relationship Question Answered: Should I Commit to this Relationship or Keep Looking?

July 5, 2017
Posted By: Kristen Hick, Psy.D.
couple sitting on park bench

In my work as a relationship therapist in Denver, Colorado, clients often question whether their partner is the best possible match and try to determine whether to keep looking for a better fit. Often this consideration is coupled by a broader “fear of missing out” (FOMO) as clients wonder whether they are settling or if there might be an even better, more “perfect” or “ideal” relationship out there.

If you too contemplate this question related to dating and commitment, consider these dynamics as you evaluate whether to commit or continue looking for a more ideal partner.

Nothing is perfect

From our earliest childhood expectations comes the idea that love should be free of disagreements, conflict, and should in some way “complete us” and our life. This very ideal view of relationships isn’t productive or realistic as we are faced with the real dynamics of couplehood, including healthy friction and a certain level of imperfection. Embracing challenges in any partnership as learning opportunities and possibilities for personal expansion is key to a happy relationship.

When contemplating whether you should commit to a relationship or keep looking, it's easy to get wrapped up in a self-dialogue that your relationships should feel more perfect, especially if you tend to compare it to your friends’ relationships by way of social media. Don’t forget that Facebook is a highlight reel of life and comparing your relationship to others on facebook isn’t a good way to determine whether it meets the right criteria for yourself. No one posts a picture of the fight they had with their significant other before their fun night out or their recent disagreement about money.

This preoccupation with a perfect relationship is also closely tied to attachment theory, whereas anxiously attached individuals often cling to what they believe to be  one ideal mate and avoidants disengage the moment the relationship feels imperfect. Tune into whether you are affected by these dynamics in light of your attachment tendencies.

The age-old saying of “nothing’s perfect” rings true more than ever when evaluating a relationship and it’s critical to ask yourself whether you can live with and embrace the specific dynamics that aren’t ideal as there will always be a list of those in any relationship.

Trust your intuition

Intuition is a powerful and often overlooked relationship consideration. Sometimes there is a core feeling that a relationship is right or wrong that we try to ignore or consciously rationalize otherwise. For example, you might have a feeling that a partner isn’t going to be healthy fit long-term. It might be unexplained by facts, and you ignore the feeling, telling yourself that because your partner fits so much of your ideal criteria on paper by having a good job, financial responsibility, and shared interests, that you should stay. Yet, this burning sense of feeling that things just aren’t right probably won’t go away and shouldn’t be ignored.

Learning to tap into your inner compass is essential in determining whether your romantic interest is worth a commitment or if you should keep looking. Let that feeling in your gut help guide your decision to stay in your relationship or seek the closure you need to fully move on and explore whether there truly is a better fit for you out there.

Get honest

Evaluating a relationship is often about getting honest with yourself. It’s so easy to tell yourself that is everything is good enough because you don’t want to be alone or fear that you will not find someone else. This can be especially the case if you feel your life needs to follow a “typical” timeline that you see your peers adhering to, which can lead you to accept who stands before you, rather than waiting for a better fit. Or, you may convince yourself that the relationship is good when it is not, which may reflect your self-esteem or sense of worthiness of a great relationship. On the other hand, if you are accustomed to conflict or drama, you might find things wrong when a relationship is going well as an excuse to disengage, especially if you have an avoidant attachment system.

Sometimes, relationship anxiety takes over. If you have ever felt overly nervous, find yourself constantly analyzing your “next move”, or found reasons to leave a partnership that was going fairly well, you might struggle with relationship anxiety. This tendency can cloud your judgement and make it difficult to be truly honest about the potential of the relationship at hand. This dynamic can also lead to continuing to date because of fear of abandonment and/or fear of missing out. Online dating can be a true distraction in situations like this as there is an never-ending stream of potential mates in your inbox daily. Get clear and honest about what you want before letting relationship anxiety drive your next move.

At Center for Shared Insight, we work with clients who contemplate this and other relationship questions daily. As specialists in attachment theory, our team helps you understand the underlying reasons you might feel the tendency to keep looking outside your relationship, or your tendency to settle too quickly. If you want to learn more about our specific approach to relationship therapy, schedule a free consultation.

Related Blog Posts
August 12, 2021
Dating Resources: Books, Podcasts, & Ted Talks

Just knowing that others are experiencing the same challenges and dynamics in relationships is sometimes comforting. That’s why we have compiled this list of resources for you to learn from other professionals who are willing to share their knowledge, research, experiences, and learnings so that others may feel less alone on their dating journey. 

Here are some top resources we often share with clients at Center for Shared Insight (some of them are even produced by our therapists!) to support their dating journey and we hope they also provide ...

July 9, 2021
3 Ways to Overcome Online Dating Fatigue

It’s Friday night and, again, you wish that your weekend plans included time with a romantic partner. Maybe you’ve been sifting through online dating profiles for months and have gone on a handful of dates, but nothing has materialized. You log into one of your online dating apps and you almost feel a sense of dread as you again look at recent matches, views, and likes. 

Does this sound familiar? Is online dating, or even dating in general, becoming a chore and leading to dating fatigue? Are you starting ...

If you have difficulty using our website, please email us or call us at (720) 644-6698
View the ADA Accessibility Statement
This website is designed for general information only. The information presented on this site should not be construed to be formal psychological or mental health advice or treatment nor the formation of a therapist-client relationship.
Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding, you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.
CSIP UPDATE - Offering Online Therapy sessions (to COLORADO residents) during Covid-19.
Our therapists are here to help you during this uncertain time. We know you and others are trying to do your part to social distance due to Covid-19, which is why we are happy to provide online therapy sessions through our secure video platform. We are here to talk with you about how we can meet your therapy needs. 
Contact us today to learn more!